Tuesday, June 7, 2011

Project Statement


Our project is focused with the scope of American “glocalization.” Our goal is to examine on the historical and sociological perspective of Mormonism in America and investigate how these perspectives are going to frame the campaigns of two potential LDS presidential candidates, Mitt Romney and Jon Huntsman. In order to understand and comprehend the unique relationship between mainstream society and Mormonism, it is vital to gain an insightful historical overview.

Mormonism originated in the New York state in the early 1800s. The initial Latter Day prophet, Joseph Smith Jr., brought about the new wave Mormon movement. In order to create a separate and Mormon society Smith took the following members to Ohio then to the state of Missouri, a place where he figured his group would steer clear of harassment and persecution. The people of Missouri responded to the strange and socially unacceptable practices, teachings and illegal practice of polygamy with violence and protest. The boiling point occurred in 1838 with the 1838 Mormon War, in which, by state order, the people of Missouri drove the Mormon settlers out of Missouri. Still unable to find a spot to establish a religious community and being expelled from multiple areas, the settlers established an identity in Nauvoo, Illinois. Shortly after the move, the persecution of Mormons continued with the assassination of its leader Joseph Smith. The torch of leadership was handed to another prominent figure in Mormonism, Brigham Young.

Despite heavy persecution and alienation, Mormons continued to preach the teachings of the Book of Mormon and the illegal practice of polygamy. But because of issues with continuing persecution in Illinois, the Church’s new leader decided to move the community to somewhere isolated. They wandered through the Midwest to get away from mainstream society in order to practice their faith freely. The Mormon exodus ended when the Mormon settlers found their “Zion,” in the Great Salt Lake Valley. Brigham Young set up colonies across the then Mexican territory and established a substantial community. When the territory became an American territory, the United States government granted governorship to Brigham Young. Shortly after, clashes again erupted between Mormons and the government because of Mormons insistence of theocracy and polygamy. They were viewed as un-American, abnormal, and cancers to American society. The problem worsened when the public of America started hearing that the religion was spreading and spreading its polygamous ways.

American President James Buchanan, deeming the Mormon movement a “rebellion,” sent troops to the territory in an attempt to squash the “uprising.” When the citizens of Salt Lake City heard that troops were approaching they preemptively attacked passing by innocent immigrants. This incident provided even worse publicity for the already struggling to fit in religion. Young surrendered to the troops and to appease the wishes of the United States government, the LDS Church banned its practice of polygamy.

Utah still remains the epicenter of Mormon culture and practice. Though the practice of polygamy still exists, it is in rare instances and most Mormons remain monogamous. Though the most controversial aspect of the religion has been excised, Mormons still remain countercultural. Most Mormons remain modest in lifestyle. The Church has a strict policy against premarital sex, as well as a strict ban against imbibing alcohol. They also maintain a very aggressive mission style of recruiting those globally around the world and the populace across the United States.

The early struggles and social perspectives reinforced amongst the populace of the time have remained intact today. The religion has become heavily stigmatized and stereotyped because of its roots in polygamy and the modest countercultural lifestyle. These kinds of impressions have created an unfair ideology and negative or distorted feeling towards Mormonism in mainstream culture. As one of the fastest growing religions in the world, Mormonism has started to permeate many aspects of modern society, lately developing prominence in the world of politics.

As the 2012 election creeps closer, two potentially serious candidates identify themselves as Mormons. Mitt Romney, former governor of Massachusetts, has already announced that he will run, and many have speculated Jon Huntsman Jr., former Governor of Utah and current Ambassador to China, will run as well. Both candidates are well qualified and competent in politics. Romney was a well-liked Governor and was in charge of running the very successful 2002 Salt Lake Winter Olympics. Jon Huntsman Jr. speaks fluent Mandarin Chinese, was praised as Governor of Utah and was appointed Ambassador to China by Barack Obama in 2009.

While these candidates are politically qualified and adept at their jobs, the focus of their campaigns and political image has been of their faith. Politics as a spectator sport shifts the focus of candidates’ stances on issues to their personal electibility. Religion is a part of this electibility and both candidates understand that the aforementioned stereotypes, ideologies, and stigmas surrounded in their Mormon faith may be a liability. Jon Huntsman Jr., in a recent article has already had to dance around his faith:

“I’m a very spiritual person and proud of my Mormon roots,” Huntsman told TIME magazine in the interview. Pressed on whether he is still a member, he said, “That’s tough to define. There are varying degrees. I come from a long line of saloonkeepers and proselytizers, and I draw from both sides. (Gehrke, p.1)”

Mitt Romney can see the role that his father’s faith played in his attempt to run for president in 1968. The Salt Lake Tribune recently ran an article highlighting the struggle of previous candidates struggles to overcome the hurdle of Mormonism in political society. Mitt’s father, George Romney, had his run at the presidency come to a halt because of the perceived notion that Mormons have been historically racist, “But questions still arose about Romney’s religion and whether it made him a racist because the LDS Church, at the time, did not ordain blacks to its all-male priesthood. (Davidson, p.1) “

While history tends to say that Mormonism has been a hindrance in the presidential runs of candidates, a new PEW statistic states that 68 % of Americans say that it would not matter to them if a presidential candidate were Mormon, 25 % state that they would be less likely to vote for a Mormon and 5 % stated they would be more likely to vote for a Mormon (http://people-press.org/2011/06/02/section-2-candidate-traits-and-experience/#mormon). This trend reflects the growing prominence of Mormonism in American society; people are coming to understand that not all Mormons are racists and polygamists. Because of the rapid growth of Mormonism, the religion may be starting to shed the stigmas once heavily attached. This is good news for these two candidates who hope to run for commander-in-chief without having to deal with the ignorance and preconceived ideas of mainstream society.

Now, we play the waiting game. It will be interesting to see how this inherent religion in politics will play out for the 2012 elections. It is important to keep perspective on politics, in terms of judging a candidate on his political stances and style of facilitating rather than his religious affiliation. If history serves as any indication Huntsman and Romney’s religions will be targeted and serve as hurdles for their run, but if the PEW statistics show a growing trend these politicians will have a legitimate a shot at the seat in the oval office.

Media Resources

Jon Huntsman Jr. on Faith and Mormonism:







Mitt Romney on Faith and Mormonism:





http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j23td71pm9c



Experience & Interview

We visited the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints, Institute of Religion in San Jose near San Jose State University:

http://www.ldsces.org/iws1/index.aspx?p=60221

We went to experience an LDS institution to see how it differed from the congregations we visited in class. The institution holds YSA Classes every Wednesday night at 7. We walked around the facility and talked to the person at the front and she said we were free to check it out. The place seemed very similar to any other religious organizations’ institute for youth. There were no men walking around with their 6 wives dressed in ankle length dresses, or people with black ties and white shirts trying to convert us, just ordinary young people gathering to talk about their faith.

Interview

We interviewed Erik Allebest, a current active member of the Los Altos LDS Ward. Erik is 32 years old and served his mission in Costa Rica for 2 years. We met Erik through a friend who attended Pinewood High School in Los Altos, a high school that was founded by a Mormon family and has a predominately Mormon student body. We wanted to ask Erik about life as a Mormon as well as his opinions on a potential Mormon president.

A & D: What do people who find out you are Mormon usually do or say?

Erik: People are usually pretty polite, but act different for sure. Once they get to know me though, they don’t even think about it. It isn’t really that big of a deal but at first people are like, “really?”

A & D: What was the experience of your Mormon mission like?

Erik: It was something that made me grow up a lot. Your in a foreign place, with just you and your companions trying to speak Spanish….it’s just hard to put yourself out there in that situation. I saw some pretty incredible things and people though.

A & D: What was the hardest part?

Erik: Well we weren’t allowed to follow sports, and I am a huge Niners fan, I may have checked a few scores once or twice.

A & D: Do you know that there are two potential Mormon presidential candidates running in 2012?

Erik: I know that Mitt Romney is running, I’m not sure who the other one is.

A & D: Do you think it is possible for them to win?

Erik: I think it is possible, but not likely.

A & D: Why?

Erik: Well I mean, you saw it with Sarah Palin last election, people try to use personal things to try to discourage people from voting for the other candidate. Like, Palin and her kids, and how she was a hick, and I think people will do that with Romney.

Resources for Further Inquiry

Club, The 700. "Mormons Are Fastest Growing Religion." CBN.com - The Christian Broadcasting Network. Web. 07 June 2011. http://www.cbn.com/spirituallife/ChurchAndMinistry/Evangelism/Mormons_Are_Fastest_Growing_Religion.aspx.

The article, “Mormons Are Fastest Growing Religion” is a brief, yet detailed, overview as to why Mormonism is the fastest growing faith group in American history. Three reasons explaining the LDS increase is for one: its message “strikes a spiritual resonance in people”, two: its aggressive missionary effort and three: its teaching emphasizes the church’s commitment to conservative and family values, and downplays its past beliefs in polygamy and racism.


"LDS Church History." The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. Web. 07 June 2011. http://lds.org/churchhistory/0,15478,3900-1,00.html.

“The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints” is the website of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints giving a wide range of information about the church. The website explains the history of the church briefly saying that in 1820, Joseph Smith retired in Palmyra, New York and offered a prayer to God. This prayer set into motion a series of events that brought forth The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. The short history of the church contains links to more detailed information including the presidents of the church, selected historical topics, multimedia resources and the Joseph Smith website.


"Section 2: Candidate Traits and Experience." Pew Research Center for the People and the Press. 2 June 2011. Web. 07 June 2011. http://people-press.org/2011/06/02/section-2-candidate-traits-and-experience/.

“Candidate Traits and Experience” demonstrates whether or not there would be a change in view of a candidate if he were Mormon. This article contains precise percentages expressing who would, and who would not be more likely to support a Mormon presidential candidate. People more likely to support a Mormon range at a staggering low number from 3% to 6%, people less likely to support a Mormon range at a higher number from 16% to 34% and dominating the poll are people it wouldn’t matter to, ranging from 58% to 80%.